Introduction
For entrepreneurs and investors utilising Australia’s Business Innovation and Investment Program (BIIP), a visa refusal can be a significant and disheartening setback. This outcome is not uncommon, as applications are subject to complex regulations and heightened scrutiny, often catching even experienced businesspeople by surprise. A refusal decision from the Department of Home Affairs can feel like the end of the road, but it is not necessarily the outcome.
Fortunately, a refusal can be challenged through a formal appeal process. This guide provides a comprehensive overview of the legal pathways available, focusing on the merits review process conducted by the Administrative Review Tribunal (ART). Understanding the reasons for refusal and the steps involved in an appeal is critical for any entrepreneur seeking to navigate this complex immigration landscape and successfully challenge an unfavourable visa decision.
Common Reasons for a Business Innovation & Investment Visa Refusal
Insufficient Financial Capacity & Source of Funds
There are many common reasons for an Australian visa refusal, and a primary one is the failure to adequately demonstrate your financial standing. The Department of Home Affairs meticulously scrutinises whether you have sufficient funds and that they were lawfully acquired.
Your visa application can be refused if there are weaknesses or gaps in your financial evidence. Common issues that can lead to a refusal include:
| Issue | Description |
|---|---|
| Inadequate Proof of Assets | Failing to provide sufficient documentation, such as complete bank statements or verifiable and independent valuations for personal and business assets. |
| Unclear Source of Funds | Not establishing a clear and verifiable trail for how your funds were earned, transferred, or made available for your move to Australia. |
| Encumbered Funds | An inability to show that your funds are unencumbered and readily available for transfer to Australia to support your business or investment activities. |
| Inconsistent Financial Records | Providing financial documents that contain discrepancies or fail to give a clear picture of your financial history and stability. |
Inadequate & Non-Compliant Business Plan
For the Business Innovation Stream, a detailed and viable business plan is a mandatory component of your visa application. A refusal can occur if the submitted plan is vague, unrealistic, or does not align with Australia’s economic interests.
The Department of Home Affairs must be convinced that you have a genuine and realistic commitment to your proposed business activities. Your business plan may be deemed non-compliant for several reasons, such as:
| Reason for Non-Compliance | Description |
|---|---|
| Lack of Specificity | The plan is generic, poorly researched, or lacks credible details about revenue projections, market analysis, and operational strategy. |
| Failure to Align with State Priorities | The proposed business does not align with South Australia’s key growth sectors, such as technology, renewable energy, or advanced manufacturing. |
| Insufficient Economic Benefit | The plan fails to demonstrate a clear and tangible economic benefit to Australia, and specifically to South Australia, through factors like job creation or exports. |
| Weak Evidence of Experience | There is insufficient proof of your business experience or managerial skills to successfully execute the plan. |
State Nomination Issues
Securing a nomination from a state or territory government is a prerequisite for most BIIP visa streams. Each state and territory has its specific and competitive criteria that applicants must meet to be nominated.
A failure to satisfy these state-specific requirements is a common reason for a visa refusal. Issues related to state nomination that can jeopardise your visa application include:
| Nomination Issue | Description |
|---|---|
| Not Meeting Nomination Criteria | Failing to meet the nominating state or territory’s specific requirements, which can include minimum investment amounts, job creation targets, or business turnover thresholds. |
| Lack of Genuine Intent | Insufficient evidence demonstrating a genuine and ongoing commitment to residing and operating a business within the nominating state or territory. |
| Inconsistent Applications | Providing information in your visa application that is inconsistent with the details submitted in your state nomination application. |
| Poor Alignment with State Goals | Proposing a business that does not align with the nominating state or territory’s current economic priorities and growth sectors. |
Request Your Free 15-Min Consultation
Navigating the ART Appeal Process
Eligibility & Deadlines for Your Appeal
When the Department of Home Affairs (DHA) refuses a visa application, the decision letter will specify if you have the right to a review. For most BIIP visa refusals, you can appeal to the ART, an independent body that re-evaluates your case on its merits.
Eligibility to lodge an appeal typically extends to:
- The visa applicant if they are in Australia
- An Australian sponsor or nominator if the application was lodged offshore
It is crucial to act quickly, as strict time limits apply and cannot be extended. The deadline for lodging your appeal will be stated in the refusal notification, but common timeframes include:
| Circumstance | Appeal Deadline |
|---|---|
| Most onshore refusals | 21 to 28 days from the date you receive the decision |
| Certain character-related decisions (onshore) | 9 days |
| If you are in immigration detention | 7 days |
Missing this deadline will generally result in losing your right to appeal.
When lodging an appeal, be aware of the financial aspects:
- An application fee of $3,496 for migration decisions (as of 2024-2025) is required
- A 50% reduction may be available if you can demonstrate severe financial hardship
- If your appeal is successful, 50% of the fee is typically refunded
Onshore applicants who lodge a valid appeal are often granted a Bridging Visa A (BVA), allowing them to remain lawfully in Australia with work rights while the review is in process.
Evidence & Submissions for Your Merits Review
The ART conducts a merits review, meaning it takes a fresh look at your case and can consider new information that was not part of your original application. This is your opportunity to directly address the reasons for the visa refusal and strengthen your case.
Preparation is the most critical phase of the appeal process and should begin immediately after lodging the review. Building a strong case involves several key steps:
You must gather new and updated evidence that specifically counters the DHA’s findings. For example:
| Reason for Refusal | Recommended Evidence to Address Refusal |
|---|---|
| Insufficient Financial Capacity | Updated bank statements, independent asset valuations, and audited financial records. |
| Deficient Business Plan | A revised and more detailed plan, robust market research, realistic financial projections, and clear alignment with South Australia’s economic priorities. |
| State Nomination Issues | Further proof of commitment to South Australia, such as business registrations or lease agreements. |
Alongside new evidence, you should prepare a detailed written submission. This document explains why the DHA’s decision was incorrect, referencing relevant legislation and supporting your arguments with the evidence you have compiled. A well-structured submission provides a clear roadmap for the Tribunal member, making it easier for them to understand the strengths of your case.
The ART Hearing & Potential Visa Outcomes
Most appeals involve a hearing where you can present your case to an ART member, and it is helpful to understand the step-by-step process for an ART hearing. The hearing is less formal than a court proceeding and can be conducted in person, by phone, or via video conference.
Departmental officers are not usually present, giving you the opportunity to explain your circumstances and answer questions directly. You may also nominate witnesses, such as an accountant or business partner, to provide supporting testimony.
Following the hearing, the ART will issue a written decision. There are several possible outcomes for your visa appeal:
| Outcome | Description |
|---|---|
| Affirm | The ART agrees with the Department’s decision, and the visa refusal is upheld. |
| Set Aside | The ART overturns the refusal. It may substitute its own decision or, more commonly, remit the case. |
| Remit | The ART sends the application back to the DHA for reconsideration with specific directions. This is often a positive outcome. |
| Vary | The ART changes the original decision in some way. |
Processing times for a visa refusal appeal can be lengthy, with BII visa cases typically taking between 12 and 24 months to finalise. It is important to be prepared for this extended timeline while the Tribunal reviews your case.
Request Your Free 15-Min Consultation
Your Options After the ART Decision
Seeking Judicial Review for Jurisdictional Error
If the ART affirms the DHA’s decision to refuse your visa, one of the few remaining options is to seek a judicial review. This process involves appealing to the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia.
It is significant to understand that this is not another merits review. The court will not re-examine the facts or evidence of your case. Instead, a judicial review focuses exclusively on whether the ART made a legal error during its decision-making process.
To be successful, you must demonstrate that a jurisdictional error occurred. Examples of such errors include:
- An incorrect interpretation of the law
- A breach of procedural fairness
- Failing to consider relevant evidence
There are strict time limits for this type of appeal, which is generally 35 days from the date of the ART’s decision. Due to the legal complexity involved, seeking advice from an experienced immigration lawyer is essential to assess whether there are valid grounds for a judicial review.
Applying for Ministerial Intervention
As a final resort, you may be able to apply for Ministerial Intervention. This involves writing to the Minister for Home Affairs and requesting that they personally intervene in your case.
This option is only available in a few situations and is rarely successful. Following new Ministerial Instructions issued in September 2025, the Minister’s power is no longer used for broad “unique or exceptional circumstances.” Instead, your request will only be referred to the Minister if it meets one of the strict, objective criteria outlined in the new guidelines. For an entrepreneur, this might include demonstrating that your case has specific attributes, such as:
- You were previously a Subclass 188 (Business Innovation and Investment (Provisional)) visa holder and would now satisfy the time-in-Australia criteria for the permanent Subclass 888 visa.
Arguments about a significant economic benefit to Australia can still be included to support a request, but the primary focus must be on proving your case meets a specific ground for referral.
How a Migration Lawyer Assists Your Appeal
Case Assessment & Appeal Strategy
Engaging an experienced immigration lawyer is a critical first step after receiving a visa refusal, and it is important to understand the key differences between a migration agent & lawyer. These legal professionals provide several key services:
- Meticulously evaluating the DHA’s refusal letter and decision record to identify any legal errors, misapplication of migration law, or overlooked evidence that could form the basis of an appeal
- Providing a realistic assessment of your appeal’s prospects of success
This evaluation helps you make an informed decision about whether to proceed with a review at the ART.
Evidence Preparation & Professional Representation
A migration lawyer provides invaluable assistance in preparing a robust case for the ART. Their support includes:
- Guiding you in compiling comprehensive and compelling evidence that directly counters the reasons for the visa refusal
- Helping gather new documents, obtaining updated financial statements, or commissioning experienced reports to strengthen your application
- Drafting persuasive written submissions that frame your case in the strongest possible light, referencing relevant legislation and legal precedents
During the tribunal hearing, your lawyer will represent you professionally, presenting your case, responding to questions from the ART member, and ensuring all procedural requirements are met. This professional representation significantly increases the likelihood of a favourable outcome.
Request Your Free 15-Min Consultation
Conclusion
A BIIP visa refusal is a significant setback, but it is not necessarily the outcome for entrepreneurs seeking residency in Australia. Understanding the common reasons for refusal, from financial capacity to state nomination issues, and effectively navigating the ART appeal process are crucial steps to challenging an unfavourable decision.
If you have received a visa refusal, acting quickly with professional guidance is essential to protecting your migration goals. For trusted experiencedise and a tailored strategy to handle your appeal, contact the experienced business visa refusal lawyers at Moya Migration Lawto secure your best possible outcome.
