Introduction
Deciding to migrate to Adelaide is a significant step, and choosing the right professional help is important for a smooth visa application process. Whether to use a registered migration agent (RMA) or an immigration lawyer is a key consideration, especially if your situation is complex, or you anticipate needing to appeal a decision.
This guide will explore the key differences between Australian migration agents and migration lawyers. Understanding their distinct qualifications, the scope of immigration assistance they can legally provide, and how they are regulated will help you make an informed choice for your specific needs when seeking a visa to Adelaide.
What are the Core Differences Between an Australian Migration Agent vs a Lawyer?
Qualifications & Training for Australian Migration Professionals
Understanding the educational and training pathways for Australian migration professionals is key when deciding whom to engage for your Adelaide visa application. Both RMAs and migration lawyers undergo specific training, but the depth and breadth differ significantly.
RMAs typically attain their qualifications through vocational education. This usually involves:
- Completing a Graduate Diploma in Australian Migration Law and Practice (generally a 12-month course) or a Graduate Certificate in Australian Migration Law and Practice (a shorter 6-month program)
- Successfully passing a comprehensive capstone assessment to demonstrate practical knowledge and skills
- Registering with the Office of the Migration Agents Registration Authority (OMARA) and maintaining this registration through ongoing Continuing Professional Development (CPD)
Migration lawyers, often referred to as immigration lawyers, have a more extensive legal education. Their qualifications involve a more rigorous and lengthy process:
- Obtaining a Bachelor of Laws (LLB) or Juris Doctor (JD), typically a minimum of three to four years of university study
- Completing Practical Legal Training (PLT), a graduate diploma that includes supervised work experience
- Being admitted to the legal profession by the Supreme Court of South Australia
- Holding a current practising certificate issued by the relevant state or territory Law Society or legal professional body, which also requires annual renewal and CPD
Since March 2021, Australian legal practitioners holding an unrestricted practising certificate can provide immigration assistance in connection with their legal practice without separate OMARA registration, using a Legal Practitioner Number (LPN).
Scope of Services & Legal Authority for Australian Visa Matters
When seeking assistance for your Australian visa to Adelaide, it’s important to recognise the differing scope of services and legal authority held by RMAs and migration lawyers. While both can assist with many aspects of the visa application process, their capacity to handle complex legal issues and provide representation varies.
Both RMAs and migration lawyers can provide immigration assistance, which includes:
- Advising on suitable visa options and pathways for your circumstances
- Assisting in preparing and lodging your visa application with the Department of Home Affairs (DOHA)
- Liaising with DOHA on your behalf regarding your application
- Representing you in merits review proceedings before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) or the Administrative Review Tribunal (ART)
A significant limitation is that an RMA who is not also a qualified lawyer cannot represent you in Australian courts, such as the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia, the Federal Court of Australia, or the High Court of Australia, should your case require judicial review.
Migration lawyers, due to their comprehensive legal training, offer a broader range of legal services. In addition to all the services provided by RMAs, an immigration lawyer can:
- Provide in-depth legal advice on complex migration matters and how other areas of Australian law (such as family law, criminal law, or administrative law) might impact your visa application or status
- Offer full legal representation in judicial review proceedings before federal courts if your AAT/ART appeal is unsuccessful or if your case involves complex legal arguments
- Handle intricate legal issues such as visa cancellations on character grounds (e.g., under section 501 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth)), health waivers, and deportation matters
- Draft complex legal submissions and affidavits required for challenging cases
Request Your Free 15-Min Consultation
Legal Professional Privilege & Your Confidential Visa Information
A crucial distinction between engaging a migration lawyer versus an RMA for your Adelaide migration concerns the protection of your confidential information, specifically through Legal Professional Privilege (LPP). This privilege can be particularly important if your visa application involves sensitive details.
RMAs are bound by a duty of confidentiality as stipulated in the Code of Conduct enforced by OMARA. This means they must keep your information private. However, this duty of confidentiality is not the same as LPP. Consequently, an RMA can be lawfully compelled by authorities, such as DOHA or a court, to disclose information or documents related to your case.
Migration lawyers, on the other hand, can claim LPP (also known as client legal privilege) over communications with their clients. This means:
- Confidential communications between you and your migration lawyer, made for the dominant purpose of the lawyer providing legal advice or for use in current or anticipated legal proceedings, are protected from compulsory disclosure
- Unless you waive this privilege, your lawyer cannot be forced to reveal these communications to any third party, including DOHA or courts
- LPP fosters an environment of trust, encouraging you to provide full and frank disclosure of all relevant information to your lawyer, even if it is sensitive
Regulation & Professional Conduct in Australian Immigration Law
The regulatory frameworks and standards of professional conduct governing RMAs and migration lawyers in Australia also differ, which can be a factor in your decision when seeking assistance for your migration to Adelaide. Both professions are subject to oversight, but the nature and extent of this regulation vary.
RMAs are primarily regulated by OMARA. Key aspects of their regulation include:
- Mandatory registration with OMARA to legally provide immigration assistance in Australia
- Adherence to the Migration (Migration Agents Code of Conduct) Regulations 2021 (Cth), which outlines their professional and ethical obligations to clients
- OMARA is responsible for handling complaints made against RMAs regarding their conduct or the quality of immigration assistance provided
Migration lawyers (or immigration lawyers) are subject to a dual layer of regulation if they are also registered with OMARA, but primarily they are governed by the legal profession’s regulatory bodies. This involves:
- Regulation by the Law Society or Legal Services Commission (or equivalent) in the Australian state or territory where they hold their practising certificate
- Adherence to stringent professional conduct rules, such as the Australian Solicitors’ Conduct Rules (ASCR) or similar state-based rules, which often impose broader and more rigorous ethical duties than the OMARA Code
- Since March 2021, Australian legal practitioners holding an unrestricted practising certificate can provide immigration assistance in connection with their legal practice without needing separate OMARA registration
- Complaints regarding the conduct of a lawyer are typically managed by these legal professional bodies, not OMARA, unless the lawyer is also an RMA and the complaint specifically relates to a breach of the OMARA Code
Request Your Free 15-Min Consultation
When Should You Choose an RMA for Your Visa Application?
When Your Visa Application Appears Straightforward
An RMA is often a suitable choice when your Australian visa application for Adelaide appears straightforward, and you primarily require guidance through the administrative process. This typically applies to situations where you clearly meet the eligibility criteria for a particular visa and do not present complex issues.
Some scenarios where an RMA’s expertise is valuable include:
- Standard temporary visas, including many student visas, visitor visas, and some temporary work visas where eligibility pathways are clearly defined
- Partner visa applications where the relationship evidence is strong and no unusual circumstances exist
- Skilled visa applications when the applicant comfortably meets the points test and other standard requirements for migrating to Australia
While simple applications like an Electronic Travel Authority (ETA) or a first-year Working Holiday Maker (WHM) visa may not always necessitate professional help, an RMA can provide valuable immigration assistance for many other visa types.
Even seemingly simple applications, such as visitor or student visas, can have specific requirements like the Genuine Student (GTS) or Genuine Temporary Entrant (GTE) criteria. An RMA possesses the knowledge to help you understand and address these requirements, ensuring your application submitted to DOHA is comprehensive.
The general migration assistance provided by an RMA in straightforward cases typically includes:
- Advising on the most appropriate visa options for your specific circumstances and your goal of reaching Adelaide
- Assisting in accurately completing all necessary visa application forms
- Guiding you in preparing and collating the required supporting documents to meet DOHA’s standards
- Lodging the visa application on your behalf
- Acting as a point of contact with DOHA for routine communications regarding your application
By focusing on procedural compliance and ensuring all documentation is correctly submitted, an RMA aims to make the application process smoother and more efficient for those with uncomplicated cases.
When You Want to Minimise Professional Fees
For individuals with simpler Australian visa cases for Adelaide, engaging an RMA can often be a more cost-effective approach. When your circumstances are straightforward and do not involve complex legal arguments or extensive histories of previous issues, the fee structure of an RMA is generally well-suited to the level of immigration assistance required.
RMAs are often a more affordable option for those who do not anticipate needing the broader legal services a migration lawyer might provide for more complicated scenarios.
The fees charged by an RMA for straightforward visa applications typically range from approximately AUD $1,000 to $5,000. However, these costs can vary based on several factors:
- The type of visa: Different visa categories, even if considered straightforward, can vary in the amount of work involved. For example, a simple visitor visa application will likely cost less than a standard skilled visa application.
- Your specific circumstances: Even within straightforward cases, minor complexities or the volume of documentation required can influence the final cost.
- The level of service: Some individuals may only require basic application lodgement assistance, while others might need more comprehensive support throughout the process, impacting the overall fee.
Many RMAs offer fixed-fee packages for standard visa applications, providing clients with certainty about the costs from the outset. In some instances, if a straightforward case requires a little more attention than initially anticipated, an agent might charge an agreed-upon hourly rate for that additional work.
It is always recommended to get a detailed written quote and service agreement before engaging an RMA. While there is a cost to any professional service, using an RMA for a simpler visa application can be a worthwhile investment to ensure accuracy and efficiency, potentially avoiding more significant expenses that could arise from errors or delays.
Request Your Free 15-Min Consultation
When is a Migration Lawyer Essential for Migrating to Adelaide?
When You Face Character Concerns, Health Waivers, or Other Legal Complexities
Engaging an Australian migration lawyer becomes particularly crucial when your visa application for Adelaide involves complex circumstances. These situations often require a nuanced understanding of Australian migration law and the ability to construct sophisticated legal arguments.
Migration lawyers are equipped with advanced legal training to tackle intricate cases that go beyond standard visa applications. Their expertise is invaluable in several specific scenarios:
- Character Concerns: If you have a criminal record or other character issues that might lead to a visa refusal or cancellation under section 501 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth), a migration lawyer can provide essential legal advice. They can help prepare detailed submissions addressing the “character test” and work to mitigate adverse information.
- Health Waivers: Should you or a family member have a health condition that could result in significant healthcare costs or prejudice access to services for Australian citizens, you might fail the health requirement. Certain visa subclasses allow for a health waiver. A migration lawyer is adept at preparing complex health waiver submissions, analysing medical reports against departmental policy, and arguing compelling and compassionate circumstances.
- Other Legal Issues: Sometimes, a migration matter can intersect with other areas of law, such as family law, criminal law, or administrative law. A migration lawyer possesses broader legal knowledge to identify and address these interconnected issues, ensuring a holistic approach to your case. For instance, if your immigration status impacts workplace rights, a lawyer can provide or guide you to appropriate legal advice.
When You Have Previously Handled Australian Visa Refusals or Cancellations
A history of Australian visa refusals or cancellations can significantly complicate your prospects of migrating to Adelaide. In such instances, the expertise of a migration lawyer is highly recommended.
Migration lawyers can undertake a critical analysis of the reasons behind the previous adverse decisions, offering an informed opinion on the viability of a new visa application or an appeal. They are skilled in identifying potential legal errors that may have occurred in the previous decision-making process by DOHA.
This legal scrutiny is pivotal in formulating an effective strategy to address the issues that led to the prior refusal or cancellation. Whether you are considering a fresh application or appealing a decision, a lawyer can:
- Guide you on the best pathway forward
- Meticulously prepare your case to overcome past hurdles
- Present your circumstances in the most favourable light
- Address the specific concerns raised in previous decisions
Their understanding of the legal framework allows them to navigate these complex situations effectively.
When You Need Representation for Your AAT/ART or Federal Court Visa Appeals
If your visa application for Adelaide is refused or your visa is cancelled, you may have the right to appeal the decision. While both RMAs and migration lawyers can represent you at the AAT or ART for a merits review, the capabilities of a migration lawyer extend further, particularly if court action is necessary.
A merits review by the AAT/ART involves a fresh look at the facts, law, and policy relevant to your case. Migration lawyers, especially those with litigation experience or specialist accreditation in immigration law, often bring enhanced advocacy skills to these tribunal hearings. They are adept at:
- Preparing complex written submissions
- Presenting evidence effectively
- Making persuasive oral arguments
Crucially, if an appeal to the AAT/ART is unsuccessful, only a migration lawyer can represent you in an application for judicial review to the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (FCFCOA), the Federal Court of Australia, or the High Court of Australia.
Judicial review is not a re-examination of the facts but focuses on whether the tribunal made a legal error. This requires specialised legal knowledge to identify and argue concepts like jurisdictional error, a domain exclusive to legal practitioners. RMAs who are not also qualified lawyers cannot provide this level of representation.
Request Your Free 15-Min Consultation
What are the Costs of Using a Migration Agent vs Lawyer for an Australian Visa?
Migration Agent Costs
When planning your migration to Australia, including to Adelaide, understanding the financial aspects of professional assistance is a significant consideration. Generally, the fees for a migration lawyer are higher than those for an RMA. This difference often reflects the extensive legal training lawyers possess, the broader scope of legal services they can provide, and their ability to represent clients in court, particularly for complex immigration law matters.
The cost of engaging an RMA can vary. For instance:
- Initial consultations might range from being free to approximately AUD 500.
- Standard visa applications, such as visitor or student visas, could cost between AUD 500 and AUD 2,750.
- More complex visa applications, like partner, skilled, or employer-sponsored visas, may range from AUD 2,500 to AUD 8,000 or more. Some general estimates place typical agent fees between AUD 1,000 and AUD 5,000 for an application.
- Assistance with appeals to the AAT or ART could cost between AUD 3,000 and AUD 10,000+.
Migration Lawyer Costs
Migration lawyers typically have a different fee structure, which can also vary widely:
- Initial consultations generally range from AUD 195 to AUD 700.
- Fees for standard or temporary visa applications might be between AUD 1,500 and AUD 3,500.
- Permanent or more complex visa applications can range from approximately AUD 2,000 to AUD 10,000, with some sources indicating costs from AUD 3,500 to AUD 7,700+ for such cases.
- Hourly rates for lawyers can range from AUD 200 to over AUD 600, sometimes reaching AUD 800, depending on their experience and the nature of the legal work.
- Representation in appeals processes will incur higher costs. For AAT/ART appeals, lawyer fees often range from AUD 5,000 to AUD 10,000+.
If judicial review in the Federal Courts is necessary, solicitor fees can be between AUD 7,000 and AUD 14,000, with additional barrister’s fees potentially adding another AUD 5,000 to AUD 10,000 or more, plus court filing fees.
Fee Structures and Additional Costs
Both RMAs and migration lawyers may offer fixed-fee packages for specific services, providing clarity on costs from the outset. For work where the extent is less predictable, hourly rates are more common.
It is essential to receive a written agreement for services, which should detail:
- The proposed services
- A breakdown of fees
- An estimate of any disbursements
Disbursements are out-of-pocket expenses like Department of Home Affairs visa application charges, skills assessment fees, medical examination costs, translation fees, and appeal lodgement fees.
Cost-Benefit Considerations
While an RMA may appear more cost-effective for straightforward Australian visa applications, investing in a migration lawyer for complex cases can be a prudent decision. The legal expertise of a lawyer can help avoid costly errors, significant delays, or the devastating impact of a visa refusal, which could lead to further expenses for appeals or new applications.
The “hidden costs” of an improperly handled complex application can far exceed the initial difference in professional fees. Some firms may offer “No Win, No Fee” arrangements, but these usually come with specific conditions and are less common for appeals; it’s vital to scrutinise such terms carefully.
Ultimately, the choice between an RMA and an immigration lawyer will depend on your individual needs, the complexity of your migration matter, and your budget. It is always advisable to obtain detailed written quotes and service agreements before engaging any professional for immigration assistance.
Request Your Free 15-Min Consultation
Conclusion
Choosing between an RMA and an immigration lawyer for your Adelaide visa application depends on your individual circumstances, the complexity of your case, and whether you anticipate needing court representation or specialised legal advice on intricate matters like character concerns or previous visa refusals. Understanding their distinct qualifications, the scope of services they can legally provide, and the nature of client confidentiality each offers is crucial for making an informed decision to navigate Australian migration law effectively.
If you are facing a complex migration issue, have had a visa refused or cancelled, or require representation for an appeal, contact Moya Migration Law today for trusted expertise and specialised legal services tailored to your needs in Adelaide. Our experienced immigration lawyers can provide the comprehensive legal advice and robust representation necessary to secure your best possible outcome and achieve peace of mind throughout your visa application process.
